What are the Key Differences?
The yr was 2008. Sony’s Blu-ray HD format appeared poised to exchange the DVD. Apple launched the ultra-thin MacBook Air laptop computer. And, in ecommerce circles, an open supply platform known as Magento Community Edition appeared on the market and began making waves as a result of excessive customizability.
Now, one or two issues have modified in the expertise world in the final 12 years. Magento is not any exception. Let’s journey again to a few of the excessive factors.
While Magento developed a loyal following with its authentic product, it wasn’t with out its points. Magento 2 was launched to deal with a few of these complaints, however was itself met with blended evaluations.
Adding to potential confusion, Magento 1 and Magento 2 aren’t singular variations of Magento. Magento additionally has Enterprise Editions. Unlike Magento Community Edition (now Magento Open Source), the product just isn’t free to obtain. However, the steep price ticket comes with the benefits of set up, configuration, and technical assist for bigger companies.
Here’s a fast define:
Magento 1 (which might imply both Magento 1 Community Edition or Magento 1 Enterprise Edition) and Magento 2 with all of the following:
Magento 2 Open Source: The free-to-download possibility with out assist
Magento 2 Enterprise Edition (EE): The on-premise, self-hosted possibility designed for enterprise companies and priced by particular person quote primarily based on enterprise dimension and complexity.
Magento 2 Enterprise Cloud Edition (ECE): Similar to EE, however pricing consists of cloud internet hosting by means of Amazon Web Services. This can be generally often known as Magento Commerce.
On April 27, 2017, Magento introduced throughout Meet Magento Prague that assist for Magento 1 would finish on November 1, 2018. The authentic announcement was so poorly acquired by the Magento Community that the ultimate End of Life date was later modified to June 1, 2020. This signifies that after this date, Magento will now not be supporting this product with updates.
It’s 2020, and also you’re studying about the distinction between Magento 1 and Magento 2. Likely this implies one in all two issues:
- You’re on Magento 1; you understand you should transfer, and also you’re making an attempt to resolve if Magento 2 makes sufficient enchancment on Magento 1 to be value the replatform.
- You’re on one other platform and are contemplating switching to Magento 2 and wish to see how the platform has advanced.
Regardless of the cause, we’re glad you’re right here. Hopefully, this deep dive into Magento 1 and Magento 2 will provide help to get a transparent understanding of the variations between the two variations and if both of them is true for your enterprise.
Magento End Of Life
As talked about in the Introduction, you’re probably not right here since you’re adopting Magento 1 for the first time. Generally, individuals get off sinking ships, not on them. This isn’t simply hyperbole or kicking an outdated expertise when it’s down—Magento has given an official date for Magento 1’s ultimate sinking.
The “End of Life” date that Magento has declared for the sunsetting of Magento 1 is June 1, 2020.
At this time, websites that are on Magento 1 gained’t abruptly disappear from the web; nonetheless, these shops will probably be in danger. Magento will now not be creating updates or safety patches for the product. Not having these patches means you can be prone to hefty fines for lack of PCI compliance, a lack of fame, and vulnerabilities to your retailer and buyer knowledge.
Even if the dangers don’t scare you, they could effectively scare away your cost supplier. One main cost supplier, Adyen, has already introduced they won’t proceed processing funds for Magento 1 clients after June 1, 2020 as a result of their considerations about lack of PCI compliance.
Beyond these safety considerations, lots of the extensions to third-party methods that you just depend on could turn into out of date, main you to pay for costly developer work to exchange the updates that Magento is now not making.
Suffice it to say, there are loads of causes to desert ship and, given the quickly approaching June date, loads of causes to do it shortly. Now the query turns into, is Magento 2 the proper selection on your exit technique? Do the enhancements that Magento 2 makes on Magento 1 justify pouring money and time into that replatform, or are you higher off increasing your possibility pool?
Magento 1 vs. Magento 2 Key Differences (Pros and Cons)
You’ve seen the writing on the wall, and also you’re questioning if it’s value it to replatform to Magento 2. Magento 2 was launched with new options to resolve lots of the bugs and disadvantages of Magento 1. And for what it’s value, it has positively made some enhancements.
But are these strides sufficient to endure the large funding that it takes to construct a model new retailer in Magento 2 after already closely investing in your Magento 1 retailer? Read on to resolve for your self.
- Has the structure modified?
- How’s the efficiency and cargo instances?
- Is it extra cellular pleasant?
- Is the admin simple to make use of?
- What cost gateways are obtainable?
- How streamlined is the checkout course of?
- Is safety a problem?
- Is there battle with extensions?
- Can I get buyer assist?
Has the Architecture Changed?
Magento 2 has added to applied sciences to enhance on the tech stack of Magento 1. In some methods, it’s a model new platform, which is one in all the causes it’s not a easy knowledge migration to modify to the new model. The structure of Magento 2 is predicated on PHP7, which opens up the platform for higher optimization and customization. Additionally, Magento 2 helps HTML5.
Magento 2 helps the Zend Framework 1 and a pair of (versus simply Zend Framework 1 for Magento 1). Magento 2 additionally now helps MySQL Percona 5.6 and higher.
Magento 2 has additionally added new applied sciences that are not obtainable in any respect with Magento 1. These embrace:
NGINX: An open-source net server that serves as a reverse proxy, HTTP cache, and cargo balancer.
Varnish: An economical various for net acceleration that may add important velocity to your Magento 2 website.
Composer: A instrument for dependency administration in PHP which might mean you can reuse third-party libraries with out bundling with supply code and scale back extension conflicts.
Symfony: A PHP net utility framework that makes it simpler to regulate the content material, performance, and feel and look of your on-line retailer.
Redis: An open supply, in-memory knowledge construction retailer makes use of as a database cache and dealer for messages.
How’s the Performance and Loading Time?
Unless you’re on the tech staff at your group, you might not care as a lot about the underlying structure and updates to the tech stack. What you do care about? What they imply for your enterprise. One of the questions you probably need answered: What is the efficiency of Magento 2? This is particularly related as your enterprise grows and you should scale with elevated site visitors calls for.
Performance is one in all the largest complaints about Magento 1. Magento 1 has common web page load speeds of over two seconds. This is an issue as a result of research have discovered that conversion charges drop off steeply per each second of load time. According to Google, two seconds is the absolute threshold for ecommerce web site acceptability.
Many of the new applied sciences talked about above have helped to optimize Magento pages for quicker supply and decreased server response time. Magento 2 is quicker throughout in frontend efficiency with web page loading speeds on common round 50% quicker on the homepage and product pages. Checkout is 38% quicker.
Even although Magento 2 has important enhancements on Magento 1 efficiency, you’ll nonetheless must be proactive about optimizing your website velocity. This not solely improves your conversion charges but in addition impacts your web optimization. Slow load instances damage crawl effectivity, which ends up in fewer of your pages being listed by search engines like google and yahoo.
It’s additionally necessary to notice that the high quality of your internet hosting could have a big effect in your general efficiency. The new applied sciences assist a bit, however if you happen to aren’t utilizing high quality internet hosting, your efficiency will undergo. Magento 2 Enterprise Cloud Commerce consists of internet hosting, whereas different variations enable the service provider to decide on their internet hosting (for higher or worse).
Is It More Mobile-Friendly?
More and extra consumers are feeling snug dwelling life on a cellphone or cellular gadget—and that features doing their looking, product analysis, and even shopping for. Mobile ecommerce is rising to the level that it’s crucial to have a mobile-friendly web site. Just take a look at these numbers:
According to this knowledge from Statista, U.S. cellular retail gross sales are anticipated to succeed in $432 billion by 2022.
In addition to interesting to a bigger and bigger swath of the shopper inhabitants, having a mobile-friendly website improves your search rankings. Google considers mobile-friendliness to be a key rating issue and has since 2015.
So how do Magento 1 and a pair of evaluate in serving to you get your cellular as much as snuff?
Mobile friendliness was one in all the main complaints with Magento 1, proper up there with website efficiency. There have been workarounds created by Magento builders and the Magento group over the years to optimize for cellular, however it’s not normal with Magento 1 themes.
Compared to Magento 1, Magento 2 is considerably extra mobile-friendly. The themes are responsive, and the checkout is optimized for cellular. Of course, whereas there are themes for Magento, most all the pieces goes to be customized and retailers will wish to make certain their builders are Magento licensed.
Magento 2 additionally helps Progressive Web Apps (PWAs) which might enable them to create a local cellular app like expertise for his or her website.
Is the Admin Easy to Use?
So far we’ve largely centered on the frontend and the way it impacts what your clients see and reply to. However, you additionally probably care about how issues work on the backend, the place you might be spending a good period of time. Does the newest model of Magento present a extra person pleasant admin panel?
The admin panel in Magento 1 was tremendous clunky and troublesome to navigate. It was additionally lacking a sophisticated dashboard which Magento 2 provides.
The admin panel is an enchancment on Magento 1 when it comes to ease of navigation, but it surely nonetheless has a steep studying curve. Numerous duties will be fairly overwhelming to setup and handle, and if you happen to aren’t doing issues in the right order, you will get caught.
The new dashboard shows final orders, new orders, and common orders; lifetime retail gross sales, prime search key phrases, revenue tax, bestsellers, and extra. It additionally allows clients to configure merchandise and customise knowledge grids to what they most have to see.
What Payment Gateways are Available?
Allowing your clients to pay with the cost gateway that’s most acquainted to them can go an extended method to constructing belief and bettering the conversion charges of your ecommerce enterprise.
With this ecommerce resolution, retailer homeowners may combine most of the common cost gateways to make use of on their Magento website. However, this often required a third-party integration or generally customized growth work.
Unlike with Magento 1, Magento 2 now helps the hottest cost gateways robotically, with out requiring extra integrations. Supported gateways embrace PayPal, Braintree, and Authorize.internet.
How Streamlined is Checkout?
According to surveys, 23% of consumers will abandon a cart if the checkout course of is simply too sophisticated. Keeping your checkout course of streamlined is a must have.
The checkout course of for this model usually concerned six completely different steps: checkout methodology, billing data, delivery data, selecting a delivery methodology, cost data, and reviewing the order. These have been troublesome to skip and have been usually introduced on separate pages.
Magento 2 makes some enhancements on checkout person expertise by simplifying the course of down to 2 steps: delivery and reviewing funds. Magento 2 additionally has accelerated checkout choices as effectively.
Is Security an Issue?
Consumers are very involved with the safety of their knowledge and are unlikely to purchase from a model they don’t belief with that knowledge. A survey of on-line purchasing habits discovered that knowledge safety and privateness ranked highest amongst elements customers take into account when deciding whether or not to purchase from a retailer. If that isn’t sufficient cause to take care of your safety, you may also face large fines and a lack of fame if you happen to are discovered to not be PCI compliant.
We’ve lined this already, however Magento 1 is shortly on its method to not having any safety patches or updates. This means you gained’t be capable of keep a safe website with out some very costly growth prices to create and replace these patches for you. After June 1, 2020, having a safe website and having a Magento 1 website will probably be basically incompatible.
With Magento 2, your website will be as safe as you wish to make it. You could have patches and updates, however you’ll nonetheless have to handle PCI compliance by yourself. Magento 2 is technically PCI compliant if you happen to don’t make any modifications, however basically nobody makes use of an unmodified model of Magento, therefore why you are taking up the accountability of PCI compliance administration by yourself. Much like Magento 1, the extra you customise your Magento retailer, the more durable putting in future replace and patches turns into, so managing your PCI compliance can shortly turn into burdensome.
This differs from SaaS platforms like MassiveCommerce that handle the PCI compliance of the underlying platform for you.
Is There Conflict with Extensions?
It’s unlikely that any ecommerce platform will be capable of serve all of the enterprise wants of your ecommerce retailer, which is the place extensions are available in. How extensible is your platform, and the way simple is it to combine needed extensions?
Another ongoing criticism with Magento 1 has traditionally been that there have been loads of issues with conflicting third-party extensions. It wasn’t all the time simple to get a number of extensions to work collectively.
Magento 2 improves this subject by permitting extensions to overlap. New applied sciences like HTML5, CSS3, and REquire.js additionally make it simpler to put in extensions. That mentioned, extensions can nonetheless be laborious to handle as you customise your Magento retailer.
Can I Get Customer Support?
Sometimes you simply need assistance to get your retailer working the manner you need it to. Which model, if both, is ready to give you that assist?
After June 2020, you gained’t obtain any patches or updates from Magento to assist your retailer. You are by yourself, a lifeboat adrift at sea.
With Magento 2, the degree of buyer assist will depend on which model you are working with. As we talked about in the introduction, Magento 2 covers each Magento Open Source, Magento Enterprise Edition, and Enterprise Cloud Edition. Only the latter two choices present assist, and so they additionally include a steep price ticket. Magento Open Source is free to obtain, however doesn’t include buyer assist.
Who Wins the Battle, Magento 1 vs. Magento 2?
Realistically, this isn’t even a query. Magento 1 and Magento 2 aren’t actually at battle as a result of one is a viable ecommerce platform and the different is a dying star that may quickly now not even be a safe place to construct a website.
If you are at present on Magento 1, your solely query (which I guarantee you we are going to get to shortly) is whether or not it is best to put money into shifting to Magento 2 or solid a wider internet for different choices.
Migrate to Magento 2, How Much Will It Cost?
If you do select to migrate to Magento 2, your funding is more likely to be steep. (One extra cause it’s good to suppose lengthy and laborious earlier than making a call.)
Trusted Magento 2 growth company Exinent estimates medium-sized ecommerce website may cost $50,000 on the low finish and take 5 months to finish, and that’s if in case you have a minimal of customizations. (A fast take a look at your calendar will let you know: you don’t have 5 months.) They additionally advocate that you just take a look at the price to construct your Magento 1 website and add one other 10% to that.
When is the Time to Migrate to Magento 2?
The finest time emigrate from Magento 1? Several months in the past. The second finest time to migrate from Magento 1? As quickly as doable.
Your time is operating out as June shortly approaches. You’re doing due diligence by beginning to evaluate Magento 2, however in actuality, there are various different choices it is best to vet which will higher serve you in the future.
After you make your ultimate choice, you’ll nonetheless have a full replatform forward of you. As talked about above, even if you happen to transfer to Magento 2, it is not going to be a easy knowledge migration, however nearer to a full replatform. You might want to not solely transfer all of your knowledge, but in addition arrange needed integrations and develop your website’s UI and UX. And in fact, it would be best to make certain to go away time to check all the pieces earlier than going dwell.
Should I Just Leave Magento?
Now we come to the actual query: does it make sense to look past Magento 2 and take into account your options? This all will depend on your enterprise and its particular wants.
You could have gone to an open-source possibility initially since you didn’t suppose a SaaS resolution may deal with the degree of customization you wanted. However, because you’ve been on Magento 1, issues in the SaaS world have modified.
An open SaaS resolution like MassiveCommerce with versatile APIs can mean you can construct what you need, seamlessly connect with extensions, innovate with artistic digital experiences, and scale as you develop. MassiveCommerce additionally helps choices like headless, together with Progressive Web Apps, which have beforehand required an open supply platform. You will even then have all the advantages of SaaS together with internet hosting, dependable efficiency, and safety. (Note: Magento Enterprise Cloud Edition additionally consists of internet hosting, however not PCI compliance.) Essentially, except you will have excessive customization wants, MassiveCommerce could possibly present you the website you want at a decrease whole price of possession.
Has Magento 2 made the kind of progress you want so as to make it your subsequent ecommerce platform? Or is it time to maneuver on to one in all the revolutionary options on the market? Only you’ll be able to reply that query…and you should reply it shortly.